TEAM MANAGEMENT
Are You Dealing with an Overfilled Appointment Book graphic of book with appointment papers sticking out

By Louise Dunn

D

uring the pandemic, it seemed as if everyone was suffering from the stress of too many appointment requests and not enough hours in the day to see all the patients. Fast forward to today, and your practice is still likely suffering from this same problem. Looking back, is it possible that appointment scheduling snafus were an issue before the pandemic, and the pandemic just exacerbated an existing problem that continues up to today?

Unfortunately, how you scheduled appointments may have already been on the verge of breaking years ago. An overbooked appointment schedule may be one symptom. To fix this, you need to look deeper into the root cause of your scheduling snags and what you can do about them.

FINDING YOUR SCHEDULING SWEET SPOT
FINDING YOUR SCHEDULING SWEET SPOT
A sweet spot is a particular point where something will be most effective or beneficial. For the appointment schedule, it is where there is the correct number of appointment openings to provide access to care and allow for the delivery of exceptional medical service without overwhelming the team. That sweet spot is also where there are enough openings, but not too many openings that the business suffers a financial crisis. So, where is your scheduling sweet spot?

To find out, you first need to dig a little. More specifically, you need to find out where your practice’s capabilities match client needs in a way your competition can’t.1 And this starts with identifying three key elements: your competition, your clients’ needs, and your capabilities. Achieving the sweet spot for optimal scheduling requires a strategic process that looks at all three elements.

venn diagram showing the sweet spot that balances vet's capabilities with client's needs
venn diagram showing the sweet spot that balances vet's capabilities with client's needs
Recall that the sweet spot is where your practice's capabilities match your clients' needs in a way your competition can't.
Know Your Competition
Yes, you have probably looked at your competitors’ websites and even made those phone calls to gather pricing information. However, did you drill down on how their clients request or schedule appointments? Did you find out what the wait time is for an open slot? Knowing your competition is vital to keeping abreast of what is happening in your market, so look at veterinary practices and retail (box store) clinics. Also, look at human medical and dental offices as well. Even though they offer a different service, they try to satisfy similar client needs.

Listen to what your clients are saying. Did they switch to your practice because their last veterinarian never had any openings? Do they talk about how easy it is to schedule with their dentist but scheduling an appointment for their pet takes twice as long and feels as if they have to jump through hoops to do it? In the big picture of competition, your competitor is anyone your client compares you to, so look beyond veterinary and monitor trends in other industries.

Know Your Clients
Learn what your clients think about your service and what they want. To do this, just ask them! They will tell you what they expect. There are several ways to do this: conduct a survey, including an email or text a link to a survey; ask a quick question at checkout; or include a message with the survey link on the invoice.

Asking, “How easy was it to schedule your pet’s appointment?” sounds simple enough, but let’s get a little more specific. You must explore the entire client journey—from requesting an appointment to checking out—because all those touchpoints factor into setting up your appointment schedule. You may want to select a specific group of clients, making sure it is diverse (e.g., age of clients and pets, services requested, time and doctor preferences, scheduling methods preferred, etc.).

Consider asking your clients for suggestions on technology use, automated processes or other customer service innovations they feel would be beneficial. Using technology can not only improve the client experience, but it can also improve how the practice allocates time and schedules the team.

Know Your Capabilities
Assess the strengths and weaknesses of your standard operating process (SOPs), from requesting an appointment to in-hospital experience to post-visit contact. Do you experience snags at registration or discharge? Is the length of time allotted to different appointment types correct? Is the wait to get an appointment causing clients to look elsewhere? Is the wait time from the lobby to the exam room causing clients to leave? Is the need for treatment or tests causing the team to run behind on appointments, backing everything up until closing? Where are your office inefficiencies? Are the phone lines always tied up? What is your office capacity?

Identify what capabilities you need to develop to overcome scheduling snags, best serve your clients’ needs and efficiently schedule the team.

Taking Action
If you are constantly having trouble with office hours, your SOPs for scheduling appointments need to be changed; you can’t keep doing the same thing and expect a better outcome. Doing the same thing is still giving you overbookings, upset clients, burned-out team members and causing you to run behind schedule. So what are your options?

Recall that the sweet spot is where your practice’s capabilities match your clients’ needs in a way your competition can’t. You looked at what competitors were doing, asked key clients about their needs and assessed your capabilities. Your next move depends on your findings, but here are some things your colleagues are doing to improve access to care and relieve appointment headaches:

  • Holding huddles to review the schedule and map out a plan of action
  • Reserving slots for same-day appointments
  • Reserving times for walk-in appointments
  • Forward booking appointments
  • Setting up a 24/7 veterinary nurse advice line
  • Conducting virtual exams
  • Establishing Technician/Nurse appointments
  • Using a transcriptionist in the exam room (e.g., a vet assistant or using a virtual transcriber)
  • Creating an Admit Nurse position
  • Creating a Floater DVM position to handle walk-ins, emergencies, work-ups, and care for hospitalized patients
  • Repositioning what team members are responsible for so as to work at the top of their license more effectively (e.g., not having a veterinarian draw blood when a technician or assistant can do it)
  • Conducting client education classes instead of using up exam room time (especially for puppy and kitten topics)
  • Creating a Physician Assistant position utilizing veterinarians who graduated out of the country and have yet to be licensed in the U.S.
  • Contracting with a semi-retired veterinarian to conduct virtual consults
  • Streamlining paperwork by completing it electronically in advance of the appointment
  • Changing exam room procedures to mitigate inefficiencies (e.g., the use of scribes or Fear Free techniques).

Some of these options address available time slots to mitigate overbooking, others expand access to care via other means of seeing a medical professional, some seek to reduce time spent in an exam room, and others utilize different positions to handle the workload. There is no one-and-done solution found on this list, but it demonstrates that your colleagues are thinking beyond only an overflowing appointment schedule.

Your action plan depends on your pain points because your practice is unique, as are the mix of patients you see, procedures you perform and treatment plans you recommend. Your choice also depends on where you want to develop your capabilities for future client and business needs. Don’t take the stance that “this too shall pass;” that your scheduling problem resulted from the COVID pandemic, and you will soon be back to your old ways.

Efficiency and Productivity
Efficiency and Productivity
An overfilled appointment book could be just one symptom of a more significant issue—one of efficiency and productivity.

The following are efficiency indicators to track each quarter:

  • Team and DVM hours per transaction (should be 1.33-2.33 for best efficiency)
  • Revenue / FTE DVM
  • Invoices / FTE DVM
  • Support-team wages as a percentage of revenue.

Start with the numbers from the past year and set goals for the next quarter. Implement a few changes to how appointments are scheduled and how the team is scheduled to see if it changes the numbers.

In addition to efficiency indicators, conduct a time study to track how much time is needed for your services. After all, there have been advances in technology and changes to your standard procedures over the years—did you ever evaluate how these changes affect time slots for different services? Then, look outside the box (the exam room box, that is) for ways to change how you deliver your services to patients.

For example, can the practice have a virtual team performing virtual visits which then opens up exam rooms for other visits? Can a tech/nurse conduct client education via a Zoom call (such as new puppy/kitten issue or dealing with an ongoing long-term condition), thus relieving the strain on the appointment book from unavailable exam rooms? It behooves you to consider future business performance by looking at what weaknesses were exposed, what responses you made (or didn’t make), and where the future of patient care and client experience is going.

What constitutes the best appointment schedule is evolving…as is what clients value and expect in their veterinary experience. The veterinarian continues to lead patient care, but now shares the responsibility with other team members. The client sees those other team members as extensions of their pet’s veterinarian and is comfortable working with a team of veterinary healthcare providers.

Reimagining how your practice sees patients and communicates with clients goes beyond time slots on a computer screen. It is about improving access to care and staying connected with clients. It involves taking into consideration the wellbeing of the team in addition to the patients. The goal is to achieve schedule efficiency (both staffing and patient scheduling) without sacrificing accessibility or quality of care. Take time to determine your scheduling sweet spot and improve how you provide care to your patients.

References
  1. Collins, D., Rukstad, M. (2008, April). “Can You Say What Your Strategy Is?” Harvard Business Review, page 89. https://idea-sandbox.com/blog/strategic-sweet-spot/
Louise Dunn headshot
Louise Dunn is a renowned award-winning speaker, writer and consultant. She brings over 40 years of in-the-trenches experience and her business education to veterinary management. Louise is founder and CEO of Snowgoose Veterinary Management Consulting. SVMC works with veterinarians who want to develop a strategic plan that consistently produces results. Most recently Louise received many awards including the WVC Educator of the Year numerous times and VetPartner’s The Life Time achievement Award in January 2016.